Time to end costly ‘Beauty Contests’

By Frank McKenna

By Frank McKenna

The latest tranche of ‘Levelling Up’ grants were announced this week. Whether your area was a winner or a loser the bidding process is fatally flawed and should be scrapped according to DIB boss Frank McKenna.
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on whatsapp
Share on email

First the good news. A new tranche of funding has been announced by the government to support its ‘Levelling Up’ agenda (if that’s what they’re still calling it). Among the winning projects are the Eden Project in Lancashire, the regeneration of Gateshead Quays, and the regeneration initiative in Blackpool.

£40 million has been awarded to West Yorkshire Combined Authority to transform its bus services. The North East Combined Authority will receive £20 million to buy electric buses. Cheshire, Greater Manchester, and Merseyside authorities also received support for a range of projects. Altogether there were 111 grants given out across the UK.

However, the West Midlands didn’t get anything, whilst the ‘Blue Wall’ – places like Rutland, north Somerset, and the Malvern Hills are on the list. Some are suggesting that the polls are so bad that Rishi Sunak is shoring up support in traditional Tory areas – and the so-called Red Wall has already been abandoned.

Indeed, despite denials to the contrary, the loud whisper in Westminster is that ‘Levelling Up’ is yesterday’s news – a Johnsonian soundbite that – even if the party-loving, blonde bombshell was genuine about it – had little or no prospect of being delivered in a meaningful way.

Whatever the truth, here is a fact that nobody can argue with. Local authorities, with scarce resources to start with, are encouraged by central government to work up bids and submit them for consideration.

Councils from across the country spend literally millions of pounds preparing their evidence to get the green light for their transformational projects from Whitehall civil servants – and most of them are left disappointed, out of favour, and out of pocket.

These ‘beauty contests’ among cash strapped councils are a huge waste of limited cash and resources. Levelling Up funds ought to have been distributed in an equitable fashion through Combined Authorities, who could then decide where best in their place money should be invested.

The charade of pitting poor areas against other poor places is crackers. It is a process that the government needs to review and stop.

Many congratulations to those who were successful in this latest bidding round. But if you add up the totals of what it has cost all the unsuccessful ‘contestants’ to pull their bids together, one can’t help but feel that there is a massive false economy being encouraged and promoted by ministers and Whitehall mandarins. What a waste of money!

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on whatsapp
Share on email
Downtown in Business
Which department is your enquiry regarding. If unsure select other.
Please summarise why you are contacting Downtown in Business.

A Baptism of Fire

Rishi Sunak has not enjoyed much of a honeymoon period as Prime Minister. Frank McKenna reflects on the baptism of fire the new man in Number 10 has had to face.

Read More

Brexit isn’t working

A litany of facts prove that leaving the EU was a mistake. But are British politicians ready to accept the fact that they need to have an open and honest conversation with the electorate about the need for a more pragmatic approach to be adopted towards our European neighbours?

Read More